Originally Published in 'Sonar
Bangla', July-August, 1996. A Tribute to Kanika Banerjee, by Pijushkanti Sarkar. Translated from Bengali.
 |
| Kanika Banerjee |
‘Baaje Karuno Sure’ -
How the song, being of love, does sublimate to its inner mystery! The
exposition of that on the other hand does kill the lay. That isn’t desired. ‘Path’, ‘Pathik’, ‘Panthha’, ‘Panthhabeena’ - these come and go, now
and then. This is where; Rabindranath proves to be a Baul. ‘Hay Dure’ in the song is as if a refrain.
It is heard that this melody is similar to a South Indian composition, rendered
by Sabitri Krishnan. In recent times Swagatalakshmi Dasgupta is at first enthralling
and then making her listeners more and more acquainted by rendering such original
compositions along with Rabindranath’s adaptations, during various occasions,
onstage. Don’t take me otherwise. I do not mean to say that none is aware of
those compositions, but letting listeners recall those tunes, is an obligation
of any responsible artiste. Hence does Swagata prove very appropriate.
If one
checks the published notations of the song, admirers may lose a part of their
interest. It is very essential that a separate version of notations, following
what Mohordi has sung, is published without delay. It’s raga ‘Simhendramadhyam’.
We know how wonderfully Pandit Ravishankar had presented the raga, through his
records. However I find more of ‘Kirwani’
in the song. The sanchari seems to have an influence of ‘Madhumanti’. Whatever
it may be the fact remains that one can never dare to render this unless one
has expertise over Carnatic Classical Music - it isn’t that easy. Mohordi has
good expertise - that’s the secret behind her voice so care freely opening in
the rendition. Her voice is like a viola
- sounds as if a bowing instrument is playing on and on. The playing on her
voice beings with ‘Baaje’ - the halt
at tivra madhyam induces an uncanny melancholic feeling. A similar feeling is
induced with the ‘Marwa’ raga. This very feeling has been aroused by the famous
Ray in his ‘Manihara’ through this
song in a wonderful sequence. It is a peerless application - Rumadi had
rendered. That was an experience of its own. But Mohordi’s version has no
moving picturisation, it’s just for being heard. We get to see the visualizations
on hearing, in our inner eyes.
SONG : BAAJE KARUNO SURE
RECORD NUMBER : 7EPE 1046
RELEASE : OCTOBER-NOVEMBER, 1967
 |
| The Living Viola |
The song seems to take one to speechless
meditation - how heavenly Mohordi’s voice was! Nothing else - Kanika just
utters ‘Baaje Karuno Sure Hay Dure’.
Immediately it seems that the ‘Charanatalachumbita
Paanthhabeena” begins to play on its own. I know it would be too much if I
now speak on the magic of the words, for if I once begin, I will get more into
discussing it. Yet, I just can’t resist myself! Just imagine, has any poet ever
seen the ‘Path’ (the way) as a ‘Veena’ (Veena, the instrument)? That
too, with ‘Charanataler Chumban’ (kissing the divine feet) drawn on the
canvas? I do not know how this can happen! ‘Taba Charanatalachumbita Paanthhabeena’ - Your
divine feet have touched the way seemingly in the form of a Veena. Hence has it
begun to play! What a fancy! Notably, with what fine affection Mohordi has
uttered ‘Paanthhabeena’. Her voice
touching the shadaja of the madhya saptak, as if a South Indian woman, having
amazingly perfect Bengali pronunciations, is rendering the masterpiece - that’s
the feeling I get!